Business Essentials
Can you really be the person people can't live without? Gerard McManus inspects some of the best thinking on indispensability.
First, let's clear up a few fallacies. Popularist strategies on how to make yourself indispensable in the workplace include: placing yourself strategically besides the photocopying machine so when the contraption breaks down, you are the ready expert; becoming the office IT expert; the social co-ordinator (who could possibly dismiss the person who organises Christmas parties?); the crisis manager (what do we do if something goes really wrong?) or simply by ingratiating yourself with the boss or upper management.
In larger, more sophisticated organisations this supposed building of an impregnable force field of "must-have" would be the equivalent of becoming chief operating officer, chief information officer, head of human resources or being attached to these positions of power and influence.
In short, conventional advice on indispensability is a combination of blending in to corporate culture, embedding yourself into an organisation at the highest level, or hiding.
But the idea of turning yourself into an octopus, a chameleon, a limpet or a ghost is not good long-term strategy.
The fact is, no one is indispensable. Check your pay slip to verify.
Nevertheless, in the current climate where uncertainty is the norm and business outlook is unpredictable, indispensability is something upon which people at various levels of an organisation place great value.
Beyond pop advice there are constructive ways of thinking about your role from a higher level, which will increase the odds in your favour.
They will give you not only a better perspective, but also make your career more satisfying in the long-term.
Warning on terminal uniqueness
Understanding this concept is a first step towards making yourself a more valued commodity to your organisation.
As Seth Godin, a thinker who has spent a lot of time researching this topic, says: "Someone can always do your job a little better or faster or cheaper than you can." In his book Linchpin: Are You Indispensable? (Portfolio/Penguin) Godin also warns that trying to take out insurance may even be counter-productive.
"If you are deliberately trying to create a future that feels safe, you will wilfully ignore the future that is likely."
Furthermore, organisationally speaking, indispensability is actually a risk factor and the idea of systems design is to eliminate this particular risk. In other words, anyone whose function is ultimately not replaceable is a potential cost to that organisation should that person leave or be dismissed. Any good internal auditor will tell you they look for people seen as indispensable and increase risk weighting in their areas.
And the reality is, even in worst-case scenarios where someone has buried all particular knowledge or data or procedures which are valuable to an organisation and is removed from their job, the resultant dust storm is likely to be days or weeks rather than months.
Building on strengths
A 2006 Harvard Business Review article titled "Making Yourself Indispensable" has been one of the journal's 10 most popular articles over the past decade. It still sells and you can buy it online for $6.95.
However, before you do, it is worth noting there is nothing specific in the article about making yourself indispensable.
Rather, its authors, John H. Zenger, Joseph R. Folkman and Scott K. Edinger, analysed the challenges of building on strengths as against fixing weaknesses.
It is a technique identified by Peter Drucker four decades ago and acknowledged and updated by the authors.
"Unless an executive looks for strength and works at making strength productive, he will only get the impact of what a man cannot do, of his lacks, his weakness, his impediments to performance and effectiveness," Drucker wrote in The Effective Executive. "To staff from what there is not and to focus on weakness is wasteful - a misuse, if not abuse, of the human resources."
In one key suggestion the HBR authors suggest "cross-training" for leadership skills including the following:
- Identify your strengths;
- Choose a strength to focus on according to its importance to the organisation;
- Select a complementary behavior;
- Develop it in a linear way.
